being a bitch check
11/19/2026
For the past several years, Elio and I have been texting each other to ask for a “being a bitch check:” this has saved me a number of times from acting badly in the heat of the moment, and has made several relationships both more honest and worse. Making tiktoks for Bookends gave me an extremely strong aversion to talking about race in public. Anyways, here are two things I recently said in a group chat that I wanted to expand on:
- White women do love to be like this thing I don’t like is racist and unchic and ugly as well. And I’m always like well it’s impossible to say which of those problems have gotten under your skin most lol
- I think a lot of white writers who understand themselves to be people who care about race have made this kind of lateral move where they continue to write about white people but understand their project to be in some fundamental way about or commenting on whiteness
This can be a helpful frame analytically [eg. that any given white writer’s work can be read as about whiteness] and a limiting or self-excusing one in your own practice. Whether you want it to be or not, your work will be about whiteness. What is incumbent on you, then, is to decide whether you force the reader who isn’t looking for that into encounter with it.
I think a great deal of white writers are essentially afraid to write characters of color because experiencing their own clumsiness in doing so will force them to face up to some uncomfortable truths: it’s easier to think of yourself as incidentally insightful by way of refusing to try at all. There is, of course, the confident overcorrection— reading (for example) Gretchen Felker-Martin write from a black perspective is not dissimilar to watching someone lay a rake on the ground and step on it. Any seriously antiracist white artist has to just be willing to eat shit, I think. It’s a part of craft that there are few rewards to sharpening, except that not doing it makes you look like an asshole to people who are paying attention [ME!]. But it feels important to me to say that the inability to write race is a failure of craft, not just (“just”) of ethics or politics: it betrays an inability think in a fundamental dimension of the world you occupy. To circumlocute race is to write characters outside of history.
I think that there are more likely to be career consequences for stumbling in giving someone who isn’t white a consciousness than there are for never trying at all. This is only really true on a technicality, though, because the level of egregiousness you have to reach in order for it to cause you a problem makes me want to bang my head against a wall until I black out [see, again, Gretchen Felker-Martin]. I also think that most [white] people basically don’t care if their friends and collaborators are racist in ways that they understand to be minor- otherwise, how the hell do you ever get anything done- and that people are often reactive to racism allegations in that they assume them to be both probably true and made in bad faith- which, to be fair, they usually are. It’s hard to want to be critical of how anyone writes about race when I think the likely outcome of that is not anyone writing about race differently but rather
- white people seizing any pretext to wokely launder privately-felt social hierarchies (see: “unchic”) and
- more people deciding it’s not worth the trouble.
I used to be more likely to tell people that I found I Saw the TV Glow frustrating because of how clear it is that the lead character was written as white and cast “neutrally,” leaving a film that seems to be incapable with engaging with its own blackness, but then most people independently decided to be embarrassed about liking it because they like feeling above people who have been on hormones for less time than them, so they’ll flatly agree with any criticism instead of giving me a nervous blank stare until I stop talking.
I’ve been thinking lately about the ways that people refuse to engage black ideas as ideas, another nominal overcorrection that is materially about a half-step from total disengagement. Often people who are otherwise keen observers of social dynamics are reticent to name something as racist, much less to pick apart its interpersonal mechanisms unless they’re reached a point of unavoidability. I’d like people to be more willing to risk being wrong, not to refuse critical thinking because it unsettles a sense of oneself as nebulously fallible but in any specific instance, of course, either right or well-intentioned. If the only time you call something racist is when intending it as a mechanism for social ostracism, I don’t think you care. It doesn’t matter if you’re right— you probably are. As you learned in 2020, most things are racist.
In No Name in the Street, James Baldwin says of William Faulkner that “Faulkner’s portraits of Negroes, which lack a system of nuances that, perhaps, only a black writer can see in black life— for Faulkner could see Negroes only as they related to him, not as they related to each other— are nevertheless made vivid by the torment of their creator. He is seeking to exorcise a history which is also a curse.” I was so struck by this. I read it on the train to work and rolled it around in my head until I could copy it out during my boss’s break. What Baldwin gets at is an ambivalent and infuriating dimension of accidental success through cruelty— what I am concerned about and frustrated by in my peers is most often intentional failure, an imagined world where people of different races simply do not relate to each other at all, where any contact is as a passing moment of disjuncture. Cruelty has specificity, and teeth. Sometimes I go to parties and watch white women decide not to learn my name: I’m trying not to be grateful to be invited, anymore.
BEING A BITCH CHECK: I’m on my period right now. I wrote most of this in a coffee shop that was busier than I wanted it to be. I worry all the time about alienating my white friends: I resent this worry in myself and it makes me angry at and mistrustful of people I care deeply about. I think we all make excuses for each other and for the art we’re invested in and I don’t think that’s always the worst thing in the world. Are you mad at me? Do you think I’m too mean?
***
currently reading:
listening to:
watching: